Tried & True
By Connor Tien, DougCo Social · Updated September 2026
Every place on this page, we actually went — ordered the food, paid the bill, and wrote it up in the newsletter with a date on it. No scraped review averages, no paid placements, no places we haven’t set foot in. Click through to any listing for the full verdict, dish by dish.
2026 visits
Castello Italiano — Castle Pines
September 2026 (opening week)Bar seat on night three: bison short rib ravioli ("really good"), a Caesar that doesn't take over the meal, and both desserts — the Italian lemon cake wins.
Published in DougCo Drop, Sep 10, 2026
ClueClock Escape — Castle Pines
September 2026Tried the new live Game Show with the DougCo Social squad: "It was a back-and-forth game, but I'm happy to report that my team (the red team?) ended up victorious!"
Published in DougCo Drop, Sep 3, 2026
Denver Polo Club Sunday Funday — Sedalia
September 2026The final Sunday Funday: $39 GA, tailgates full, Wide Open Saloon pouring, Westernaires between matches. "This event is for anyone and everyone."
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Sep 8, 2026
The Colorado Bluegrass Festival — Castle Rock
August 2026McAwesome Ranch, 7th year: "Music was amazing, ranch was (mc)awesome." Highlights were Salomé Songbird, Before the Sun, and Tome.
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Sep 1, 2026
JP Cocina & Cantina — Parker
August 2026 (opening night)Crashed the opening party. "Street corn and the ribeye tacos: 👌."
Published in DougCo Drop, Aug 20, 2026
Boondocks Food & Fun — Parker
August 2026"It might be heaven on earth." Bumper boats over go-karts (got soaked), the claw-machine arcade, two mini-golf courses, the ropes course.
Published in DougCo Drop, Aug 13, 2026
Savina's Mexican Kitchen — Castle Rock
August 2026The Wednesday lawn concerts: hay bales, margaritas shaken on barrels, $8 handheld burritos, Front Range views.
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Aug 11, 2026
Tony's Meats & Market — Castle Pines
August 2025 + August 2026Birthday skewers first (Cajun pork the winner), then a year later: "You took my breath away with your butter." All the meats, all the sides.
Published in DougCo Drop, Aug 13, 2025 and Castle Rock Crew, Aug 11, 2026
Woodhill Small Batch BBQ — Douglas County (truck)
July 2025 + August 2026His Fair go-to two years running — brisket, pulled pork, baked beans. Memphis Sweet + sausage is the combo.
Published in DougCo Drop, Jul 30, 2025 and Castle Rock Crew, Aug 4, 2026
Jet's Pizza — Castle Rock
July 2026Detroit-style education: Hawaiian and Chicken Bacon Ranch "tasted amazing," but "there's a lot more bread than topping."
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Jul 28, 2026
Rugby Scott — Parker
July 2026The new Mainstreet butcher — American Wagyu, a Thor’s Hammer shank, five generations of family story.
Published in DougCo Drop, Jul 9, 2026
Emagine Theatre — Parker
June 2026Sneak-preview tour with the owner — heated recliners, cuddle chairs, EMX screens, 900° pizza oven.
Published in DougCo Drop, Jul 2, 2026
Griddled Crêpes & Paninis — Castle Rock
June 2026 (three visits)Trailblazer Panini, Nutella Mascarpone & Strawberry crêpe, and the secret-menu Dulce de Leche Latte.
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Jun 16, 2026 and Jun 23, 2026
Sunday Salmon — Castle Rock
September 2025 + June 2026The donation-optional community restaurant: Tuesday Tacos from the food truck at Unity on Park. "Add it to the summer bucket list!"
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Sep 16, 2025 and Jun 9, 2026
Cados — Castle Rock
Standing pickThe breakfast-burrito champion — first stop on the show-friends-around-town list.
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Jun 9, 2026
Carla's Barbershop (Cifredo) — Castle Rock
May 2026Wedding-season cut from Cifredo: straight-razor work, clean fades, businessman cuts. "He made me look halfway respectable."
Published in Castle Rock Crew, May 5, 2026
The Parker Hotel — Upper Deck — Parker
April 2026"One of the best rooftop patio views in Parker."
Published in DougCo Drop, Apr 23, 2026
Starbird Chicken — Castle Rock
April 2026Invited himself to the friends-and-family opening.
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Apr 21, 2026
Legends Coffee — Parker
March 2026Pre-opening visit with owners Jake and Tabitha — a six-year location hunt ending on Mainstreet.
Published in DougCo Drop, Apr 2, 2026
Bar Hummingbird — Castle Rock
March 2026The Coco Encanto mocktail: "honestly one of the best drinks I’ve had in a while." Lobster roll "next level."
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Mar 31, 2026
Egg Harbor Cafe — Highlands Ranch
March 2026Soft opening with his parents — Strawberry French Toast, Harborcinnos, and a shared cinnamon roll.
Published in DougCo Drop, Mar 19, 2026
Poulette Bakeshop — Parker
July 2025 + March 2026Prosciutto & brie tart "hands down the best." There for day one at the Mainstreet location.
Published in DougCo Drop, Jul 9, 2025 and Mar 12, 2026
Playa Bowls — Parker
March 2026Grand-opening protein bowl, straight after three Poulette pastries.
Published in DougCo Drop, Mar 12, 2026
Marvin's Place — Parker
March 2026The no-WiFi café at The Juniper — "This is the good part. Don’t miss it."
Published in DougCo Drop, Mar 5, 2026
The Par Club — Castle Rock
March 2026 (grand opening)Six golf simulator bays, full bar, lounge and TVs in the Safeway center off S Perry. "A really unique spot with a nice elevated feeling."
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Mar 10, 2026
Buff City Soap — Castle Rock
February 2026Checked out the new downtown location after the move from the Outlets.
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Feb 17, 2026
Perry's Steakhouse & Grille — Lone Tree
February 2026"My life before experiencing Perry’s has now ended." The famous pork chop beat the ribeye.
Published in DougCo Drop, Feb 5, 2026
Doug's Diner at Bucket List Tavern — Castle Rock
January 2026Breakfast under the new Doug's license: after going back and forth with the breakfast burrito, the huevos rancheros won, "which I really enjoyed."
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Jan 27, 2026
Jack's Modern Steakhouse — Lone Tree
January 2026Opening week, before the fire — the otoro stood out; Wagyu ribeye "Champion style" worth trying once.
Published in DougCo Drop, Jan 22, 2026
2025 visits
Homegrown Tap & Dough — Castle Rock
December 2025Sneak peek — Rustic Ranger pizza "amazing," and "nothing but ringing endorsements on all of the dishes."
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Dec 30, 2025
West Main Taproom + Grill — Parker
December 2025Homemade meatballs, brisket tacos, 54 Colorado taps. Filed under "reliable and worth returning to."
Published in DougCo Drop, Dec 10, 2025
Black+Haus Tavern — Parker
November 2025The chicken pot pie was the standout of the night — his first ever ordered at a restaurant.
Published in DougCo Drop, Dec 3, 2025
Provision — Castle Rock
November 2025Burger the standout, fries + aioli the sleeper combo. "Definitely going into my regular rotation."
Published in DougCo Drop, Nov 26, 2025
Apres Coffee (in Ecclesia) — Castle Rock
November 2025Ran the fall menu with Madi — Fudge Break won.
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Nov 18, 2025
Oo•de•Lally Coffee — Castle Rock
November 2025The Christmas Flight — Rudolph (white chocolate, caramel, cherry) was the winner.
Published in DougCo Drop, Nov 19, 2025
Blue Island Oyster Bar — Lone Tree
November 2025Oysters flown in from their own Long Island farm; the prosciutto-wrapped scallops are the must-order.
Published in DougCo Drop, Nov 12, 2025
Bien y Tú — Castle Rock
November 2025"Upscale without the attitude." The Lawsuit crunch wrap, the carnitas bowl, and orders to get the key lime pie next time.
Published in DougCo Drop, Nov 5, 2025
Castle Cafe — Castle Rock
October 2025The Castlewood Canyon salad, finally — "medjool dates in a salad = chef’s kiss."
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Oct 14, 2025
Wide Awake Eatery — Castle Rock
June + October 2025Breakfast first, then dinner: Leah’s Penne alla Vodka, stolen truffle fries, and "great value."
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Jun 3, 2025 and Oct 21, 2025
Trifecta Sports Bar & Grill — Castle RockClosed
October 2025Soft-opening visit — Bison Burger with brie, pool tables, Buck Hunter. Now closed.
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Oct 21, 2025
Venalonzo's Tacos — Parker
October 2025The go-to quesabirria, from a Yelp Top-100 taco spot — "the birria consomé for dipping seals the deal."
Published in DougCo Drop, Oct 29, 2025
GQue BBQ — Lone Tree
October 2025Brisket "perfect" with the pink ring, jalapeño sausage the sleeper hit, then Ice Cream Farm next door. "If you haven't been, go."
Published in DougCo Drop, Oct 8, 2025
The Brinkerhoff — Castle Rock
September 2025First Monday after opening — burrata "an easy 10/10," and the French Dip stacked up.
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Sep 30, 2025
Ovest Via Ristorante — Parker
September 2025Pork-belly Brussels, braised short rib over saffron risotto, and a Sticky Date Cake he'd "make the drive back just for."
Published in DougCo Drop, Sep 24, 2025
Trestles Coastal Cuisine — Castle Rock
September 2025Brunch after multiple impressed dinners — blue crab omelet, "not a single miss around the table."
Published in DougCo Drop, Sep 17, 2025
Cranelli's — Lone Tree
September 2025Garlic knots, arancini over raspberry jam, half Chicken Parm, and the panna cotta that "absolutely stole the show." Expect a wait at 6pm.
Published in DougCo Drop, Sep 10, 2025
Duke's Steakhouse — Castle Pines
September 2025French onion soup, the 14 oz ribeye with a loaded baked potato, and the tavern side. "Neighborhood go-to, not white tablecloths."
Published in DougCo Drop, Sep 3, 2025
Sazón — Lone Tree
August 2025Salsa flight and tableside guac, Divorciadas enchiladas, and Baja lobster and shrimp enchiladas that "stole the show at the table."
Published in DougCo Drop, Aug 27, 2025
Mashawi Damascus Cuisine — Castle Rock
August 2025Falafel, hummus and "kabobs of every sort" at the rebranded Damascus Grill by the library. "10/10 would recommend."
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Aug 26, 2025
Teaology Tea Cafe — Castle Rock
August 2025A coffee guy trades up: Thai Tea and Palisade Peach, plus the Southwest Spicy Muffin.
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Aug 19, 2025
Wolf Peach Public House — Parker
August 2025"Lived up to the hype." Whipped ricotta with strawberries and hot honey; the espresso-cocoa lamb won.
Published in DougCo Drop, Aug 20, 2025
Castle View Cafe — Castle Rock
July 2025Breakfast tacos with "some kick" in the old Vista Vino space, from the Stonegate Cafe folks.
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Jul 22, 2025
Scileppi's at The Old Stone Church — Castle Rock
July 2025The 1888 church: house-made pastas, East Coast pizza, and both the PB Cup Reese Pie and the Colossal Cheesecake ("yes, I had both").
Published in DougCo Drop, Jul 16, 2025
Sierra — Lone Tree
July 2025"Make a reservation. It’s a well-oiled machine." Santa Fe Enchiladas, covered patio, perfect evening.
Published in DougCo Drop, Jul 2, 2025
LaLa's — Castle Rock
June 2025"Walked out with a new favorite spot" — gluten-free pastries that taste nothing like gluten-free pastries.
Published in DougCo Drop, Jun 25, 2025
Union An American Bistro — Castle Rock
June 2025Southwest salad, and PB Bites "excellent and extremely cheap."
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Jun 10, 2025
Ito Sushi Asian Bistro — Castle Rock
April 2025A tough critic who grew up on LA sushi was impressed: the 2-Toro Roll and the Mayo Roll. Best for groups of four or fewer.
Published in Castle Rock Crew, Apr 15, 2025
FAQs
What is Tried & True?▾
Tried & True is the DougCo Drop newsletter’s first-person review franchise: one local restaurant, bar, or coffee shop actually visited and written up each week, alongside the Castle Rock Crew review paragraphs. This page indexes every published visit, dated, with the full verdict on each place’s directory listing.
Are these reviews paid or sponsored?▾
No. Paid placements are excluded from this page by rule — sponsor copy never doubles as a review here, even when the visit was real. Everything listed was eaten and paid for as a regular customer, and published in the newsletter with a date.
How do I get my restaurant reviewed?▾
You can’t buy your way on. Open in Douglas County, be worth writing about, and reply to a newsletter to say hello — new openings and reader recommendations drive where we go next.
New Tried & True editions land in the newsletter first
One place, actually visited, every week — before it hits this page. Join 15,000+ Douglas County locals. Free.
Subscribe free →