Highlands Ranch has a brand-new cookie shop, and its cookies already have a following.
Joy Batch Cookies & Coffee (formerly Quinnie's Cookies) is now open at 9315 Dorchester St, Unit 109, near S Broadway. It opened with a grand opening on Friday, Oct. 9.
The basics
- Owner: Sarah Carlson, who ran Quinnie's Cookies before rebranding and relocating to this Highlands Ranch storefront
- What: cookies, coffee and curated gifts, per the owner's announcement
- Where: 9315 Dorchester St, Unit 109, Highlands Ranch, CO 80129, near S Broadway
- Hours: Tuesday-Saturday 9am-6pm, Sunday 9am-2pm (or until sold out); closed Monday, per joybatch.com, checked Nov. 15, 2026
- Ribbon cutting: the Castle Pines Chamber of Commerce is hosting a ribbon cutting at the new storefront on Tuesday, Oct. 20, 4-5pm
In her own announcement, Carlson thanked the community for the support that got the shop to this point: "We truly couldn't have opened our doors without the overwhelming encouragement, excitement and support from all of you."
The backstory: from Quinnie's Cookies to Joy Batch
Carlson started what became Joy Batch as a small home baking business, Quinnie's Cookies, in 2023, after a career in sales and advertising. It grew through pop-ups, events and catering before this Highlands Ranch storefront, the business's first standalone shop. The baking goes back further: she grew up the fifth of seven kids, baking with her mom and sisters, per her own About Us page.
What it costs
Per the menu board, photographed on opening day, Oct. 9, 2026:
- Double Decker Cookies (regular size): single $4.75, 6-pack $27, dozen $48
- Quinnie's Minis (mini size): dozen $30
- The Welles Batch (tiny cookie bites): 20 ct. $30
- Coffee: Latte $6.50, Cappuccino $6, Americano $5, Espresso $3.50, Drip Coffee $3, Hot Chocolate $4, Joy Freeze $7, Shaken Milk $4, Chai Latte $6 (add a flavor for $0.50)
- Cold drinks: Bottled Water $3, Sparkling Water $3, Mini Soda $2.50, Alani $4, Chocolate Milk $2.50, Milk $2.50
Coming up
The Castle Pines Chamber of Commerce's ribbon cutting is Tuesday, Oct. 20, 4-5pm, at the shop.
We went on opening day
We went on opening day, Oct. 9, and got there early enough to make the first 100, so we got the free chocolate chip cookie the shop was giving its first 100 guests. We brought home five cookies total, including that free one. My ranking, best first:
- Toffee Pretzel
- Cookies & Cream Cheesecake (the one with the Oreo on top)
- Peanut Butter Cup
- Cake Batter Confetti
- Chocolate chip (the free one for the first 100)
Flavor names are from the labels in the case on opening day. The cookies come in the regular Double Decker size or as Quinnie's Minis, and the 6-pack and dozen prices on the menu board work out cheaper per cookie than singles.
Joy Batch sold out again the next day, Saturday, Oct. 10, the second day of its grand opening weekend. Its own post that day: "DAY TWO… SOLD OUT AGAIN!"
The rhythm, four days in
We stopped back by on Tuesday, Oct. 13, and talked with Sarah about how the first week has gone. That week, the day started with a coffee hour at 9am, with a limited selection out, dozen packs and dipper cookies, before the full cookie case came out at 10am, and the shop closed at 3pm. Her goal then was to stay open until 6pm once full production was running. As of Nov. 15, joybatch.com lists Tuesday-Saturday hours of 9am-6pm and Sunday hours of 9am-2pm.
Joy Batch sold out again on Tuesday, Oct. 13, after selling out on opening day and that Saturday. Go earlier in the day for the best selection.
We also tried a sample of the Joy Freeze ($7 on the menu board) and liked it.
The coffee is her brother's organic beans; he's based in Louisiana, and the shop sells bags of them too.
There's no gluten-free option yet. Sarah wants to get it right before she offers it here. Her goal is a safe GF option within the next month or so.
What's next
Hours and details are on Joy Batch's directory listing. Also see our best coffee shops in Highlands Ranch roundup.
Sources: Our visit on opening day, Oct. 9, 2026, including photos of the menu board; our visit and conversation with owner Sarah Carlson on Tuesday, Oct. 13, 2026; joybatch.com for hours, checked Nov. 15, 2026; Sarah Carlson's own grand-opening announcement and countdown posts on Instagram (@joy.batch), September-October 2026, including the Sept. 24, Sept. 29 and Oct. 1, 2026 posts and the Oct. 10, 2026 "sold out again" post; the Castle Pines Chamber of Commerce's ribbon-cutting announcement on Instagram and its public event listing for Oct. 20, 2026; ShoutOut Colorado's interview with Sarah Carlson; Sarah Carlson's own About Us page on joybatch.com for the backstory, checked Nov. 15, 2026.