Top-rated by the people who go there
Ranked on Google ratings and review counts (Yelp too, where we have it) · ratings refreshed September 2026 · 6 italian restaurants in our Castle Rock directory
Pasta, pizza and red sauce done right. Here are the top-rated Italian restaurants in Castle Rock, ranked on Google ratings and review counts.
Each restaurant links to its directory page with the address, hours and website.
Family-owned Italian staples served in a historic 1888 church. Cozy atmosphere, great wine, cocktails, and dishes like chicken marsala and ravioli.
Stylish and energetic spot serving elevated Italian and New American dishes with a lively patio.
Italian comfort food with brunch, happy hour, sports TV, and cocktails in a relaxed Castle Rock spot.
Casual, family-friendly spot serving Italian and Mexican favorites with quick, friendly service in Castle Rock.
Cozy Italian restaurant known for generous portions, authentic recipes, and a warm neighborhood vibe in Castle Rock.
Every place in our Castle Rock directory whose main category is italian restaurants gets a score from its Google rating and review count, with Yelp weighed in where we have it, so a 4.8 with 600 reviews beats a 5.0 with three. A place needs at least a 4.0 Google rating and five reviews to be ranked, closed places are out, and a second location of the same name only counts once. Every spot earns its place on reviews alone. The ratings were last refreshed September 2026, and the order updates itself when they change.
Love a place on this list? A Google review is the best way to help it climb. If a place has closed or the details on its page need an update, tell us and we'll fix the directory, which fixes this list.
Right now the top three by our score are Scileppi's at The Old Stone Church, Danielle's Scratch Kitchen, Z'Abbracci - Pizza, Pasta & Tap House. The full list above has 5, ranked out of the 6 italian restaurants in our Castle Rock directory.
Scileppi's at The Old Stone Church is #1 on this list with a 4.5 Google rating from 2090 reviews. That can change as reviews come in.
Every place in our Castle Rock directory whose main category is italian restaurants gets a score from its Google rating and review count, with Yelp weighed in where we have it, so a 4.8 with 600 reviews beats a 5.0 with three. A place needs at least a 4.0 Google rating and five reviews to be ranked, closed places are out, and a second location of the same name only counts once. Every spot earns its place on reviews alone. The ratings were last refreshed September 2026, and the order updates itself when they change.
Our Castle Rock directory lists 6 italian restaurants. 5 clear the bar for this guide; the rest are in the directory with the same hours, address and rating details.
New spots, local events, and insider tips delivered weekly. Join 14,000+ Douglas County locals.
Subscribe Free