About
⚠️ CLOSING WED AUG 26, 2026: Final day at 138 S. Wilcox is Wednesday, August 26 (posted hours 11am–8pm; a last day can end early). Read more →
Background: Stumpy's has to leave 138 S. Wilcox Street after Rivers Church went under contract to buy the building. The restaurant is open here through the end of August 2026, then relocating — the owners are still searching for a new location. Read the full story.
Stumpy's Pizza delivers classic New York-style thin-crust pizzas alongside popular bar fare in a casual, no-frills atmosphere filled with arcade games and pinball machines.
The friendly service, strong drink selection, and family-friendly environment with wheelchair accessibility make it a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike.
What To Expect:
- 🍕 Authentic NY-style thin-crust pizzas
- 🍗 Boneless wings and comfort food favorites
- 🎮 Pinball and arcade games for fun vibes
- 🍻 Extensive beer and cocktail selection
Important Information:
- Reservations: Not accepted
- Payment: Credit and debit cards accepted
- Parking: Free lot and street parking available
- Accessibility: Wheelchair accessible entrance, restrooms, and seating
Family and group friendly with a casual environment ideal for lunch, dinner, and solo dining.
📍 Local Insights
🚚 Relocating: Rivers Church is buying the building, so Stumpy's is leaving 138 S. Wilcox after its final day on Wednesday, August 26, 2026 (posted hours 11am–8pm; a last day can end early). Manager Gretchen Norton says they're trying to reopen elsewhere and it will "just take a few months," though no new address has been announced. Support them in their final weeks here.
🎯 Lunch Specials: The two-slice lunch deal with a beer offers great value, well-loved by locals.
🕹️ Arcade Fun: Guests enjoy pinball machines and arcade games, making it ideal for family visits.
🍻 Bar Vibes: The bar serves a solid beer and cocktail selection, creating a casual, social atmosphere.
🚗 Parking Ease: Plenty of free parking in both the lot and street, convenient for all group sizes.
Closed
This business has closed, so no hours are listed. Try instead: open restaurants in Castle Rock →
👉 Best For
- •Families
- •Casual groups
- •Lunch
- •Dinner
- •Arcade fans
Also In
Best Restaurants in Castle Rock →Location
138 S Wilcox St, Castle Rock, CO 80104Review Sentiment
Based on 631 Google reviews
"Stumpy's Pizza is highly praised for its authentic New York-style thin-crust pizzas, friendly bar service, and lively arcade atmosphere. Customers love the lunch specials, garlic knots, and wings. However, some reviews mention inconsistent service and party size restrictions, while a few note issues with order accuracy and staff responsiveness."
What You'll Find
- •New York-style Pizza
- •Garlic Knots
- •Boneless Wings
- •Burgers
- •Salads
- •Beer
- •Cocktails
- •Arcade Games
- •Pinball Machines
📆 Best Times to Visit
Weekday lunch and early dinner avoid the evening rush; arcade games popular with families early evening.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Castle Rock Crew · free weekly email
I send the new spots worth trying in Castle Rock every Tuesday morning. No crime, no politics, no noise.
DougCo Social Experiences
We don’t just cover Douglas County — we get people together in it.
Small-group dinners, a sunset supper club, and paint nights we host across the county. Come to one and you’re in.
See our experiences →✱ Similar
Mashawi Damascus Cuisine
Authentic Syrian and Mediterranean dishes with fresh ingredients, casual family-friendly vibe, and a standout chicken shawarma in Castle Rock.
Stack'd
Fresh-to-order burgers, cheesesteaks, and fries served in a casual Castle Rock spot known for friendly vibes and community spirit.
105 West Brewing Company
Veteran-owned brewery serving a wide variety of fresh craft beers and sours with great service and heated patio seating.