About
⚠️ UPDATE (July 2026): Stumpy's has to leave 138 S. Wilcox Street after Rivers Church went under contract to buy the building. The restaurant is open here through the end of August 2026, then relocating — the owners are still searching for a new location. Read the full story.
Stumpy's Pizza delivers classic New York-style thin-crust pizzas alongside popular bar fare in a casual, no-frills atmosphere filled with arcade games and pinball machines.
The friendly service, strong drink selection, and family-friendly environment with wheelchair accessibility make it a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike.
What To Expect:
- 🍕 Authentic NY-style thin-crust pizzas
- 🍗 Boneless wings and comfort food favorites
- 🎮 Pinball and arcade games for fun vibes
- 🍻 Extensive beer and cocktail selection
Important Information:
- Reservations: Not accepted
- Payment: Credit and debit cards accepted
- Parking: Free lot and street parking available
- Accessibility: Wheelchair accessible entrance, restrooms, and seating
Family and group friendly with a casual environment ideal for lunch, dinner, and solo dining.
📍 Local Insights
🚚 Relocating: Rivers Church is buying the building, so Stumpy's is leaving 138 S. Wilcox at the end of August 2026 and looking for a new home. Support them in their final weeks here.
🎯 Lunch Specials: The two-slice lunch deal with a beer offers great value, well-loved by locals.
🕹️ Arcade Fun: Guests enjoy pinball machines and arcade games, making it ideal for family visits.
🍻 Bar Vibes: The bar serves a solid beer and cocktail selection, creating a casual, social atmosphere.
🚗 Parking Ease: Plenty of free parking in both the lot and street, convenient for all group sizes.
⏰ Hours
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 11:00 AM–8:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM–8:00 PM
Thursday: 11:00 AM–8:00 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM–9:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM–8:30 PM
Sunday: Closed
👉 Best For
- •Families
- •Casual groups
- •Lunch
- •Dinner
- •Arcade fans
Also In
Best Restaurants in Castle Rock →Location
138 S Wilcox St, Castle Rock, CO 80104Review Sentiment
Based on 623 Google reviews
"Stumpy's Pizza is highly praised for its authentic New York-style thin-crust pizzas, friendly bar service, and lively arcade atmosphere. Customers love the lunch specials, garlic knots, and wings. However, some reviews mention inconsistent service and party size restrictions, while a few note issues with order accuracy and staff responsiveness."
What You'll Find
- •New York-style Pizza
- •Garlic Knots
- •Boneless Wings
- •Burgers
- •Salads
- •Beer
- •Cocktails
- •Arcade Games
- •Pinball Machines
📆 Best Times to Visit
Weekday lunch and early dinner avoid the evening rush; Fridays and Saturdays get busiest between 5 PM and 8 PM; arcade games popular with families early evening.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
DougCo Drop
Join 12,000+ Douglas County residents who get weekly picks, local deals, and insider tips.
Join for Free →DougCo Social Experiences
We don’t just cover Douglas County — we get people together in it.
Small-group dinners, a sunset supper club, and paint nights we host across the county. Come to one and you’re in.
See our experiences →✱ Similar
212 Pizza Co.
Casual and cozy pizza spot with unique crust and organic ingredients; gluten-free and vegan options; friendly service and lively atmosphere.
Angie's Restaurant Castle Rock
Casual, family-friendly spot serving Italian and Mexican favorites with quick, friendly service in Castle Rock.
Arayes Grilled Stuffed Pitas
Casual spot serving fresh grilled stuffed pitas with lamb, falafel, and vegetarian options in Castle Rock’s Ecclesia Market.