Skip to main content
Best OfBest Italian Restaurant in Douglas County

Douglas County · Best Of

Best Italian Restaurant in Douglas County

Red sauce, wood-fired, or a from-scratch kitchen — Douglas County has strong Italian options. Vote for the one you would take out-of-town guests to.

Vote for your favorite →One click. Already a Castle Rock Crew or DougCo Drop subscriber? You're in. New here? Voting adds you to DougCo Drop.
Category
Italian
Ranked
7 spots, all of Douglas County
How it's decided
Reader vote + Google & Yelp
Voting
Open now · updated daily

🗳️ Reader's Choice

Anyone can see the results. To vote you just need to be a Castle Rock Crew or DougCo Drop subscriber — not one yet? You'll be added to DougCo Drop when you vote (free, one step). One vote per category, change it anytime.

Cast your vote — Best Italian

One vote per category — change it anytime. Pick a spot, drop your email, done.

Reader's Choice — Live

updates as votes come in

No votes yet — be the first.

Best Italian Restaurant in Douglas County, Ranked

Ranked #1 to #7 by Google and Yelp ratings and review volume, refreshed as reviews come in. Tap through for hours, menu, and address.

1
Cranelli's Italian Restaurant in Lone Tree, Colorado
Cranelli's Italian Restaurant
Lone Tree · ⭐ 4.6 (3,520 reviews)

Visitors consistently praise the friendly, attentive service and flavorful Italian dishes like Chicken Parmesan and garlic knots. The restaurant's cozy atmosphere and strong drink program including cocktails and wine are highlights. Some find parking difficult and note the space can get loud and crowded during peak hours. Standouts include Garlic Knots, Chicken Parmesan, Lasagna, Baked Ziti, Stuffed Mushrooms. It's a local pick for family dinners, casual dining, groups, Italian comfort food lovers.

The standout: the Garlic Knots — a local favorite at Cranelli's Italian Restaurant.

2
Scileppi's at The Old Stone Church in Castle Rock, Colorado
Scileppi's at The Old Stone Church
Castle Rock · ⭐ 4.5 (2,076 reviews)

Scileppi's garners praise for its authentic Italian dishes, warm historic atmosphere, and attentive service. Guests love the pizza, chicken marsala, and cocktails. Standouts include Chicken Marsala, Braised Short Rib Ravioli, Big Mac Pizza, Cannoli, Gnocchi. It's a local pick for family dinners, date nights, Italian cuisine lovers, casual groups.

The standout: the Chicken Marsala — a local favorite at Scileppi's at The Old Stone Church.

3
Ovest Via Ristorante in Parker, Colorado
Ovest Via Ristorante
Parker · ⭐ 4.5 (286 reviews)

Ovest Via Ristorante is praised for its exceptional made-from-scratch Italian food, particularly calamari and sticky date cake, alongside attentive bartending and cozy atmosphere. A few review serious issues with allergy handling and group events, but most appreciate the quality and ambiance. Standouts include Calamari, Chicken Parmesan, Short Rib Ravioli, Arancini, Homemade Gnocchi. It's a local pick for date nights, family dinners, groups, scratch pasta lovers.

The standout: the Calamari — a local favorite at Ovest Via Ristorante.

4
Homegrown Tap & Dough - Parker in Parker, Colorado
Homegrown Tap & Dough - Parker
Parker · ⭐ 4.5 (432 reviews)

Excellent hand-tossed pizza with creative toppings. House-made pasta is a standout. Warm, inviting atmosphere with unique Colorado-themed decor. Great craft beer selection. Popular for families and date nights alike. Standouts include The Kicker Pizza, Weekend Warrior Pizza, Funguy Pizza, Homegrown Pizza, Chicken Parmesan. It's a local pick for pizza Night; Family Dining; Date Night; Happy Hour; Casual Dinner; Groups.

The standout: the The Kicker Pizza — a local favorite at Homegrown Tap & Dough - Parker.

5
Mici Italian in Parker, Colorado
Mici Italian
Parker · ⭐ 4.5 (469 reviews)

Mici Italian is praised for its fresh dough, authentic-tasting pizzas, and friendly staff creating a welcoming family atmosphere. Reviewers appreciate gluten-free options and quick service. Standouts include Margherita Pizza, Giardino Pizza, Pietro Pizza, Calzone with various fillings, Gluten-Free Pizza Crust. It's a local pick for families, quick casual dining, pizza lovers, gluten-free diners.

The standout: the Margherita Pizza — a local favorite at Mici Italian.

6
Z'Abbracci - Pizza, Pasta & Tap House in Castle Rock, Colorado
Z'Abbracci - Pizza, Pasta & Tap House
Castle Rock · ⭐ 4.4 (1,293 reviews)

Z'Abbracci delights with tasty pizza, pasta, and a cozy atmosphere with great happy hour value and attentive staff. Standouts include Margherita Pizza, Sicilian Pizza, Meatballs, Risotto Tots, Beef Short Rib Fettuccini. It's a local pick for family meals, casual dining, happy hour, brunch lovers.

The standout: the Margherita Pizza — a local favorite at Z'Abbracci - Pizza, Pasta & Tap House.

7
Portofino Pizza and Pasta in Parker, Colorado
Portofino Pizza and Pasta
Parker · ⭐ 4.4 (1,618 reviews)

Portofino Pizza and Pasta is highly praised for its authentic Italian flavors, generous portions, and attentive service. Reviewers love the garlic knots, pizzas, and dessert selection. It's popular and busy especially at dinner, with some noting occasional slower service due to packed seating. The cozy atmosphere and family-friendly patio receive consistent appreciation. Parking can be tricky but is generally free. A few mention variability in dish quality, but the management’s proactive customer care is commended. Standouts include Pizza, Pasta, Calzones, Heros, Garlic Knots with Marinara Sauce. It's a local pick for families, casual dining, pizza lovers, quick service.

The standout: the Pizza — a local favorite at Portofino Pizza and Pasta.

Been to these spots? Help us rank them.

Got a photo from a recent visit, or a tip on what to order? Share it and we may feature it on the site.

By submitting, you grant DougCo Social permission to use your photo and words on the site. Submissions are moderated.

Vote in every category

Best Italian is one of 37 Best Of categories. Cast your votes, then get the best of Douglas County in your inbox. Join 13,000+ locals.

Subscribe Free