#1
High Society Pizza
2229 Wildcat Reserve Pkwy A1 • $$
4.5
250 reviews
New York-style pizza in Highlands Ranch with crispy crusts, fresh toppings, and a casual, family-friendly vibe and excellent wings.
Pet FriendlyFamily FriendlyFamilies
3 Best Pizza in Highlands Ranch
Top-rated pizza based on Google reviews and local insights
Updated April 2026 • 3 total pizza in Highlands Ranch
#2
Nicolo's Chicago Style Pizza
9463 S University Blvd • $$
4.2
410 reviews
Casual spot serving wings, pastas, and a variety of thin-crust, deep-dish, or gluten-free Chicago-style pizzas.
Family FriendlyFamilies
#3
Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
1489 Park Central Dr • $$
4.1
1324 reviews
Family-friendly spot known for hearty Italian entrees, deep dish pizzas, and a wide selection of craft beers in Highlands Ranch.
Family FriendlyFamilies